Although the headline focusses on a obvious category of media, it really can go wrong on a lot of other categories as well.
From the link:
Plex is a hybrid streaming service/self-hosted media server.
There’s the main problem. You’re partially in control. I encourage everyone to switch to Jellyfin, even if you don’t have anything to hide.
Jellyfin is such a PITA to set up for those that aren’t more technically inclined.
Huh? It’s far easier, throw in your server IP+Port or DNS and quick connect your clients with a short code.
The bullshit claim solution by Plex makes me pull my hair out, especially on remote instances.
Even when running, it managed to break the database 3 times, with no repair tool of working, interestingly there are plenty, community built and official ones, so that problem is common.
Rebuilding takes a whole day with the intro-outro detection.
What a nightmare to administrate.
As someone who has bought a lifetime subscription a year ago i was enraged as my girlfriend told me that she got ads in Plex, turns out they just added their free streaming service in there without even asking, fuck them, Jellyfin evolved great!
Most people literally have no idea what you just wrote. I’m not saying jellyfish isn’t the superior option, I’m saying it’s less accessible.
Swim or sink.
This is terrible advice when you’re encouraging people to open up their network to the broader public without full understanding of what they’re doing.
That is my advice to the people not having a clue what i’ve wrote. You don’t want to tell me that people not able to setup Jellyfin are full aware of anything they are doing with Plex?
Not everyone should self-host, especially not people unable to watch a 10 minute setup tutorial of Jellyfin, or god forbid, reverse proxies.
Dumbing down self-hosting below the bare minimum is dangerous, but to each their own.
deleted by creator
Plex is definitely easier to set up. I’ve done it multiple times over several servers. I’ve literally never heard of the database breaking, and I’ve deleted media that was actively being watched. Meanwhile, Jellyfin fails basic metadata matching on the exact same media set and also lacks built-in SSO. One of the biggest niceties of Plex is inviting people to join and they can just immediately login with Google.
I’m not saying Plex is better, and I’m not defending their recent enshittification. It’s gotten worse, for sure. And I’m sure Jellyfin is great, but I haven’t had time to put the effort in to fix the metadata issues or create accounts so my users can switch over.
Jellyfin is so much better than Plex
Imo only in terms of privacy. I tried it a few times over like two to three days but I always went back to Plex. Jellyfin is a nice piece of software though. I can imagine my switch will happen in a few years.
Its better in terms of basicly everything for me. Plex is a pain and simply isn’t as polished
You must be kidding? Jellyfin is years behind in every aspect except being free software. The best part is that you can’t disable transcoding, which is either insane, malicious or plain incompetent. As soon as that’s an option we can start talking about the rest of it
We clearly have had very different experiences. Transcoding is optional and you can change it in the media player settings. (It works a lot like YouTube)
Also transcoding requires very little overhead on Intel systems so I would just transcode to the resolution of your device.
Well sure, I meant disabling transcoding and having it play anything. And it’s not about overhead, it’s just that I want to decide what my hardware does - I don’t want transcoding at all, ever, never ever. Not even when I’m using mobile data. The problem was always that jellyfin simply can’t play files which any player can play. I understand I didn’t really say what the issue was, sort of thought playing media files should be the bar
The problem was always that jellyfin simply can’t play files which any player can play. I understand I didn’t really say what the issue was, sort of thought playing media files should be the bar
Please open an bug ticket!
I’ve used Jellyfin for years and not had any issues with playback, let alone every single video file.
Additionally, I’ve been a programmer on the Roku client for over a year and again, never heard of someone having an issue playing every single video.
Not every single one, just the ones I tried. My tv can play anything using videolan or nova player, or anything else for that matter. I have to install jellyfin again, will do. It’s been very strange for me, with people praising jelly when it just never worked for me. And I avoided plex like the plague, but for some reason it works. Anyway, will check and file
is how you disable transcoding.
What’s “futanari,” uncle Joeldebuijn?
And like clockwork the enshittification proceeds unabated
Nice shout-out to Prospect.
More about this here: https://lemmy.ml/post/8606459
deleted by creator
All Plex authentication goes through Plex managed servers. There is no local option unless that has recently changed.
deleted by creator
Ok fair point. I still won’t use Plex for a lot of reasons, but good to know
deleted by creator
